A few months ago, I was invited to a wine tasting.
First, some context.
One of my oldest and best friends had recently started complaining about my increasingly reclusive life. According to her, I needed to start getting out more. Not clubs. Not parties. Apparently, people now attend curated dinners and immersive experiences. They also play padel and golf. Rich people, that is. I'm reliably informed.
Having already sprained my back during a golf session, and possessing neither the energy nor the tight shorts required for tennis, I shrugged and agreed to try one of her recommendations.
And so I got my first invitation. As I understood it, it was a wine-tasting dinner with a curated guest list of 12 people, specially selected for their different interests and potential synergies.
Right.
When I arrived, the first round of tasting had already happened. Which meant everyone already knew each other. And, more importantly, everyone seemed to know considerably more than I did about wine having already been through the ritual of a first bottle.
Now here's what I know about wine: It's red. And Jesus has a way of making it from water.
That is the exact extent of my expertise.
The minute I sat down, out came the French-sounding sommelier carrying a fresh bottle of whatever. She gave an impressive narrative about specially grown grapes, France, soil, climate, history and several other exotif things only a peasant would find unimpressive.
Then she came round the table and poured in the qfh or our glasses. It was at that point I realised there was a class test.
She was now coming around the table asking each person what they could smell. Err.. "perceive". Sorry what? Thought we were here to drink it and exchange phone numbers?
Everyone seemed to have something.
Blackcurrant. Oak. Vanilla. Earth. Leather. Oak? The heck does oak smell like? And how'd they get it in the grapes? I sniffed the content of my glass like glue and perceived... exactly nothing. It smelled like… red alcohol. And yet, the sommelier drew closer.
Beside me sat an elderly Ivorian lady who’d already finished her glass, asked for another pour and was currently halfway through what I believe was her third.
She nudged me.
“Quick. I need an ingredient. Anything. It doesn’t matter. Pick one too.”
“Err… saffron?”“Perfect!”
The sommelier arrived. “Saffron,” the Ivorian lady announced confidently. “Ooooooh,” said the sommelier. “Excellent.” What?
Then it was my turn.
“And you, Monsieur? What do you perceive?”
I paused. "Errr... Truffles...” I said. "I perceive a flowery undertone of truffles.” Me mome.
“Aaaaaah,” said the sommelier.
People across the table chimed in with an appreciative “oooooh,” some raised their glasses to me, even, seemingly understanding exactly what I'd said. Which was incredibly fortunate. Because I didn’t.
And that's how the Ivorian lady and I got through every single round. There were 8. By the end of the evening, people must have assumed we spent our weekends wandering through vineyards discussing soil acidity and grape consistency. I have no regrets.
Ever since then, I attend every wine tasting I’m invited to with confidence. Because if you cannot smell the truffles, clearly, you're the problem. Probably shouldn't even be in the room. Ugh.
Rory Sutherland is one of my favourite thinkers in behavioural psychology and marketing. He's the author of Alchemy, and he has a brilliant riff about wine and how strangely human beings construct value.
He calls the example Château de Obscure. I prefer Château de Bollocks. Imagine a restaurant selling Johnnie Walker. Most customers have a rough sense of what a bottle costs. So if a restaurant tries to charge you £50 for a glass, you immediately feel robbed. That's a price anchor.
Wine's different.
The restaurant can put something called Château de Bollocks 2018 on the menu and most of us have absolutely no idea what it costs. You don’t know whether the vineyard is famous. You don’t know what producing it costs. The restaurant might have paid €6 for the bottle. But surround it with language about terroir, oak, blackcurrant, vintage, provenance and nuns gently pressing the grapes between their thighs, and suddenly £40 or £50 feels entirely plausible.
But most importantly, just like we did at that dinner, the customer participates in constructing that value. If you can perceive safron, truffles and garden eggs yourself, that bottle must be exceptional. And valuable.
But this isn't about wine.
It's about brands. There are roughly two kinds of value for brands: intrinsic - what the thing does; and perceived - what experiencing the thing means. It's curated.
And businesses routinely underestimate how real that second kind of value is. When you hear phrases like “the art of brand building is dead”, this is a large part of it. The absence of deliberate effort.
If a beautiful restaurant makes dinner more enjoyable, for whatever reason, ambience, presentation, whatever, the enjoyment is real. You value it and they charge you for it. You know the Michelin star was invented by a tyre brand to encourage people to drive more and further? I digress.
If a heavy perfume bottle makes the fragrance feel luxurious, the experience is real. If apple packaging makes a product (Samsung claims it invented 3 years ago) feel superior, its superior. If an expensive wine tastes better to you because you believe it is exceptional, your brain really is experiencing a different product and in a very meaningful sense, having a better experience.
That’s the bit most people at the helm of organisations often miss. Psychological value isn't fake value, it's experienced value. It matters every bit as much as the functional stuff and becomes especially important in categories where products are becoming increasingly interchangeable.
And this is exactly why marketing, strategy and product teams must invest not just in features, but in deliberately crafting dare I say, curating - a customer experience. Because, dear reader, once you play in an environment where there's very little differentiation amidst high competition and a low switching cost, the only things that will keep your customers loyal may just be the narrative, the experience, and the value perception you've engineered in their minds.
When functional differentiation becomes smaller, competitive advantage begins migrating somewhere else... Into the language, packaging, interface, ritual, story... even memory.
Crafting a deliberate customer experience is not the decorative layer Marketing adds after Product finishes building the “real thing.” Experience is the soul of the product.
I still couldn’t tell you one bottle of wine from another. But now, I'll order one at a fancy restaurant, pause the waiter on first pour, gently swirl the glass and take a thoughtful little whiff, while making a face suggesting several generations of my family have owned vineyards… I know exactly what I’m doing.
It signals to everyone around me that I must be a sophisticated man of culture.
It automatically bestows identity.
Half the time I'd rather have a Coke and ice. But the perception it bestows is precisely what people buy. It is the culinary equivalent of a disproportionately shaped slay quin taking a bathroom selfie with her burgundy iPhone 18 Pro Max.
This is the larger responsibility brands too often overlook. What does using your product allow someone to feel, signal and believe?
Because if you leave that part to chance, somebody else will engineer it better. And charge more for the bottle.
Btw, did I mention that the dinner I attended in itself, the “curated” dinner with a selection of only 12 exclusively interesting individuals, a selection of allegedly some of the best wines in the world and accompanied by culinary treats including cheeses I can't pronounce, was not cheap?
Why did we go? Why did we insist on an encore and why have we since had at least half of the table back for subsequent “tastings”? You tell me.
Until next time.